Mindfulness: no-mind over matter

What exactly is “mindfulness,” and should Christians follow this? Check out this article by Marcia Montenegro, Christian Answers for the New Age (CANA):

Mindfulness is a Buddhist concept and practice, the seventh step of the Eightfold Path. Mindfulness is more than a meditative practice; it is an outlook on life and reality that ideally results from a type of meditation designed to cultivate detachment. Detachment in Buddhism is necessary, because Buddhism teaches that attachment to this world, to your thinking, to your identity as an individual self, and other attachments, such as desires, keep you in the cycle of rebirth.

Buddhism holds that the self does not exist, and identification with the self keeps you in that cycle of rebirth. Therefore, to achieve liberation from this cycle, one must break the attachment, so detachment is necessary. Mindfulness is the method, and detachment with ultimate liberation is its goal. Mindfulness is often defined as a moment-by-moment nonjudgmental awareness of the present. For many years, this writer attempted to incorporate mindfulness into her life prior to becoming a Christian.

Though thoroughly Buddhist, mindfulness has been heavily promoted to the secular world by Jon Kabat-Zinn (b. 1944), a Zen Buddhist, whose book, Wherever You Go, There You Are, brought him into the public eye; and by Thich Nhat Hanh (b. 1926), a Zen Buddhist from Vietnam whose books have enjoyed great success in the West. Both lecture around the United States.

Kabat-Zinn, however, is no secular person. He was a student of Zen Master Seung Sahn and is a founding member of Cambridge Zen Center. Kabat-Zinn started a system now called Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction at the University of Massachusetts Hospital a few decades ago.

News article

Below is an excerpt from an article in the Los Angeles Times. (If the link expires, you may need to Google it by looking for Los Angeles Times articles on mindfulness and/or on Jon Kabat-Zinn).

Excerpt====An emeritus professor of medicine at the University of Massachusetts Medical School, [Jon] Kabat-Zinn developed the system known as Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction (MBSR) and founded the first MBSR clinic at the university’s hospital more than 30 years ago.

. . . Today there are more than 200 medical centers in the United States and abroad that employ the MBSR model to complement conventional therapies.

Kabat-Zinn is reluctant to use the word “spiritual” to describe the approach to healthy living that he promotes, characterizing it instead as being “grounded in common sense.” . . .

“I don’t have to use the word ‘spiritual,'” he said. “Part of it is the power of silence and stillness. And part of that power is the power of healing that happens when you move from the domain of doing to being. It’s transformative.”

In fact, there have been rabbis, priests and even an imam who have taken Kabat-Zinn’s eight-week MBSR training course and told him that it deepened their experience of their own faiths.

The imam told him the practice was “totally consistent” with Islam, Kabat-Zinn said. Priests said MBSR reminded them of why they first went into the seminary and allowed them to transmit their faith more effectively to their flocks. =====<more>

Comments from a former meditator

Kabat-Zinn states in the article that mindfulness is “grounded in common sense” and is not necessarily spiritual. However, there is no basis for this statement. Mindfulness is based on a specific worldview found in Buddhism, particularly Zen Buddhism. In Buddhism, the mind is a barrier to grasping ultimate reality and truth; therefore, the mind must be bypassed. Mindfulness is designed to do this.

The concept of mindfulness has spread into the health care community, as noted in the article. It is usually taught as a form of stress reduction. If one practices mindfulness meditation on a fairly regular basis (not even necessarily every day), that person may eventually adopt the worldview behind it, leading one to believe that the process of detachment is at work. However, since the self is real, there can be no true detachment; therefore, no liberation or true peace results from mindfulness.

The techniques of mindfulness meditation lead one to enter an altered state, the same state one is in when under hypnosis. In this state, the mediator’s critical thinking and judgment are suspended, and anything can enter the mind.

Ironically, since even the mind in Buddhism is not real and one is to achieve no-mind, the term mindfulness becomes an oxymoron. Moreover, the liberation so dearly sought through Buddhism is nirvana, which is not a sort of Buddhist heaven as many think, but is actually the extinction of all illusions, including the illusion of self.

Buddhism has no supreme God, no mind, no self. Ultimate reality is sunyata, a term loosely translated as the void, or emptiness. It is not emptiness in the sense of nothingness, but rather the ultimate reality of formlessness from which all has arisen (similar to the Tao in Taoism). The belief is that the world is full of rising and falling, and peace comes with the cessation of rising and falling. But there can be no joy or peace in formlessness, because the self is not there, since there is no self.

Should you practice Mindfullness?

If you are a Christian, the basis, rationale, and goal of mindfulness is in complete conflict with a Christian worldview and with the reality presented by God in his word. Mindfulness has nothing in common with biblical meditation, which is thoughtful contemplation of God’s word.

Biblical meditation and prayer are not matters of trying to go beyond thought, either to achieve a mystical oneness with God, or to “hear” from God. Nothing like this is taught anywhere in the Bible. Prayer in the Bible is always presented as verbal praise, petition, confession, and expression of gratitude to God.

Furthermore, the concept of needing detachment goes against biblical teaching that we should remember what God has done, and vividly keep before us Christ’s atonement on the cross and his bodily resurrection. There are many desires that are good, and desire to know God more deeply through prayer, Bible study, and worship nourishes believers in Christ. There is no need to fear attachment or good desires.

Mindfulness and the practice of Christianity do not mesh and cannot co-exist.

If you are not a Christian, consider whether or not you wish to attach yourself to a teaching of non-attachment that stems from teachings that reject God, the concept of self, and the concept of an individual mind, while exalting a belief that the ultimate state is one of extinction from all desire, in which you essentially do not exist.

If you are not a Christian

This article is not to attack anyone, but to show mindfulness in the light of God’s word, the Bible. If you do not know Christ, consider reading about him in the Bible or see the article, “Who Is Jesus” to the right of this article.

Jesus said to her, “I am the resurrection and the life; he who believes in Me will live even if he dies, and everyone who lives and believes in Me will never die. Do you believe this?” John 11:25, 26

Be anxious for nothing, but in everything by prayer and supplication with thanksgiving let your requests be made known to God. And the peace of God, which surpasses all comprehension, will guard your hearts and your minds in Christ Jesus. Philippians. 4:6, 7

This entry was posted in Berean Examiner Blog, new age and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Mindfulness: no-mind over matter

  1. Iron Ur says:

    Practcing mindfulness is not a buddist only practice. If it was only buddists' would benefit, and non buddists' wouldn't.

    We live in a time where we are up to our eyelids in medical drugs that are used for everything under the sun and have no long lasting benefits and a truckload of negative side-effects that cause us to become addicted.

    if mindfulness as been reported by so many people to have postive and long lasting effects, (it has been reported to cured depresstion, bi polar disorder, people with stress, and anxiety) why would anyone argue againest it?

    Mindfulness and or meditation is not a half hour, hour or two hour practice. it is a 24/7 practice, to be mindfull and present through out the intire day.

    Think of it like this, if you were going cold turkey to pu a end to a bad habit, like smokeing. But you only stoped smoking for a few hours then went back to smokeing for the rest of the day. would you gain any postive benefits from not smoking? you would not.

    Or if you went on a diet to lose whieght, had one salad a day but kept eating as much of the fattening foods as you normaly ate, would you lose whieght? you would not.

    Remember Galilao Gallelie Argued with the Church during his day that the Sun was the center of the Solar system and not the earth, as the Church claimed it was. We know what the truth is today, even though he was forced by the Church to teach a lie, that the earth was the center.

    Mindfulness is the Same as concentration. Because Concentration is to focus on what is Present in the here and now. it doesn't mean that we are not thinking, but we are going past out thoughts.

    If you don't think about your heart beating, does it stop beating? no it does not. You heart is doing what it is suppose to do, beat.

    Being mindful, we don't stop thinking, we simply don't get caught up in our thoughts. They slip by unnoticed, the same way our hearts beat unnoticed.

    Ask any athlete, whos ever been in "The Zone" it's the same as being mindful. It's present moment awareness. Thier game is played with max effectiveness. Those who think to much during a sport stumble and fail.

    As for there being nothing in the Bible that says to practice mindfulness.

    “Be still, and know that I am God” (Psalm 46:10).

    Stillness is the same as mindfulness. Listen to those faithful who have said that mindfulness as helped them feel connected with out Lord.

    Look at what Jesus has said
    "Neither shall they say, Lo here! or, lo there! for, behold, the kingdom of God is within you. It is now, within your hearts " (Luke 17:21)

    To say we shouldn't Practice Mindfulness for it's healing effects, for "Church approved" reasons is like saying we shouldn't laugh do to it's postive benefits, Something Jesus said was Good as good Medication.

    Decern for yourelf, We must stand up for God's Truth, the way Galilao did, not the Church's 'truth'.


  2. Ranu T says:

    Thank you so much.


  3. Mindfulness meditation is the craft of utilizing simple methods to calm and balance out the mind.It is basically a mind-training in focusing,intentionally in the moment without judgment.It is a secular practice of cultivating our inherent human qualities of presence and mindfulness.This systematic strategy for focusing empowers us to pick up insight into our mental and emotional procedures,our periodic responses and their indications in our mind and body.@Amy Pearson.


  4. Manny1962 says:

    Also praying in the Spirit, we as Christians have nothing to do with any other religion, you cannot mix Christ and the world. Yes you can defend your use of Eastern mysticism, I take issue when anyone says its compatible with biblical Christianity. We as Christians are instructed as how we are to deal with depression, anxiety, worry, we are to pray to our God and Savior, not to use pagan Eastern methods. As for the efficacy of prayer, I can say without reservation, it works. Any Christian that appeals to Eastern practices is headed into trouble. Funny how these religions never say thank your "god" when happy or in good times. Paul said always pray in the Spirit whether in joy and sadness in thankfulness and dire times, not to calm ourselves, but to have our living God, deliver and protect us from oppression, depression , anxiety, rough times. The peace of Jesus Christ has no boundaries, I trust not myself during anxiety, I trust Jesus Christ, He has always delivered me, always.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s